Thatâ€™s probably the best word to describe my feelings the first time I stepped onto the range and shot an MP5 submachine gun. With virtually no recoil from the 9mm cartridge, putting two- and three-round bursts on steel was effortless.
So, when I heard about the new Black Creek Precision (BCP) 9mm AR pistols, I jumped at the chance to shoot one. The guns looked to be about the same size as the MP5A4 I fell in love with. I had not shot a BCP firearm before, and these looked like well-built guns. After spending time on the range with one, I got that elated feeling again.
9mm AR-type Guns
AR-pattern pistols are nothing new. Companies have been making them for years. However, it seems that in recent times there has been a new interest in chambering the AR pistol in 9mm.
The concept makes a lot of sense to me. The 9mm submachine gun has been a reliable performer for decades. To my way of thinking, a semi-automatic pistol in an SMG-sized package is likely to be both fun to shoot and have practical applications in home defense or other serious work.
Longer barreled AR pistols are likely to help increase bullet velocity while the size of the gun will both reduce recoil and enhance accuracy. Not only isÂ the initial shot more likely to be on target, but follow up shots will be as well.
Black Creek Precision makes a pair of AR pistols in 9mm: one with a 6.5â€ barrel and one with a 10.5â€ barrel. For this review, I obtained a 10.5â€ version. While the 6.5â€ gun has its appeal, I wanted to see what another 4â€ would do for ammunition performance.
Iâ€™m glad I went with the longer barrel as the chronograph showed me some interesting numbers on the range. Skip down to the ammunition performance section to see what I discovered.
My gun shipped with a SIG SAUERÂ SB15 pistol brace. The SB15 is designed to help increase accuracy when shooting an AR-style pistol with only one hand. The braces have been very popular with shooters since their introduction, and many AR pistols ship with them attached.
Of course, some people have used the braces asÂ an improvised stock to improve accuracy. The BATFE, however, determined that using the brace in this way makes the gun into an unregistered short barrel rifle. I won’t get into the government’s twisted logic here, but the bottom line isÂ if you use the brace as a stock, you could be charged with a federal crime.
BCP uses a special brace adapter that attaches the SB15 to the rear of the receiver. The adapter has QD attachment points on both sides, making it very easy to add a single point sling. Likewise, there are QD attachment points on the Odin Works KeyMod hand guard. The hand guard has Picatiny rails on top with KeyMod-type attachment slots at the 3, 6 and 9 oâ€™clock positions.
The upper and lower receivers are forged 7075-T6 aluminum and hard coat anodized MIL-A-8625, Type III, Class 2 black. The BCP logo is engraved on the magazine well of the gun, and pictograms are engraved to indicate positions of the safety selector. Both the finishing and the engraving looked exceptionally well done.
These pistols use Colt-style 9mm stick magazines. A single 20-round magazine ships with the gun, and additional 20- and 32-round mags are available from the company. I received both 20- and 32-round magazines for testing with the gun. They seemed very well built.
BCP uses 4140 steel for the barrels, and the barrels are threaded for the addition of a flash or sound suppressor. An A2-style flash suppressor is a standard part. The gun has a very comfortable Ergo pistol grip.
The trigger pull weight measured just a hair over 7 pounds on my Lyman digital gauge. Some might consider that a touch heavy for an AR-platform gun, however I donâ€™t consider it heavy at all on a combat-purposed handgun. When I had it at the range, the trigger pull did not seem heavy at all. The pull was even with a crisp break.
|magazine capacity||20, 32|
|weight (empty magazine)||7.5 pounds|
|finish||black hardcoat anodized|
At the Range
I was excited to get the Black Creek Precision pistol to the range to see how it would perform. As I mentioned, Iâ€™ve never had the opportunity to shoot a BCP pistol, and I was eager to see how it would perform. I was not disappointed.
I carried a virtual crate of ammunition with me to the range to run through the gun. In all, I had 10 different loads that consisted of six different defensive loads and four practice rounds. A total of six different ammunition manufacturers were represented.
Although carrying all of the ammo to the range turned out to be a bigger chore than I anticipated, Iâ€™m glad I took a lot. I shot nearly all of it, and carrying away the empties wasnâ€™t nearly as difficult.
Accuracy was quite good with the pistol. Using standard Magpul backup sights, groups of less than 2″Â were easy to achieve handheld at 25 yards. With several of the loads, near-1â€ groups were recorded. From a rest, I would expect groups of less than 0.75â€ are possible.
Recoil was so light that it wouldÂ make a lesser man giggle with glee. Iâ€™ve shot a number of AR pistols, and while I would never describe the .223 Rem as a punishing cartridge, recoil is noticeable in those guns. The 9mm, however, has so little recoil in an AR pistol that one might think he was shooting a toy.
Using a single-point Blackhawk Storm XTÂ sling for stability, I pushed the gun out to full extension and rapidly fired multiple rounds with very little muzzle rise. Likewise, I pulled the gun in tighter, and usedÂ the buffer tube to obtain a cheek weldÂ forÂ even more control. In light of the aforementionedÂ BATFE determination stating that it is illegal to use the pistol brace as an improvised stock (against the shoulder), I would recommend against doing so.
Strapping the pistol brace to my forearm adds additional stability if shooting one-handed. However, Iâ€™ve found that it is difficult using traditional iron sights in this manner. Iâ€™ve found that a red-dot sight makes aiming much easier when using the pistol brace.
However, the easiest aiming device Iâ€™ve found to use with the brace is a laser. Mounting the new Streamlight TLR-2 HL G on the hand guard givesÂ the shooter both a bright green aiming laser and a 720 lumen white light for target identification. Frankly, having both a white light and a secondary sighting system on the gun makes a lot of sense even for shooters not using the arm brace.
All of the ammo ran flawlessly in the gun. I shot the gun using both the 20- and 32-round magazines. All of them fed perfectly and performed exactly as they should.
|Federal 9BPLE 115 gr JHP +P+||1,467 fps||550 ft-lbs|
|Federal Champion 115 gr FMJ||1,271 fps||413 ft-lbs|
|Hornady Critical Duty 135 gr FlexLock||1,084 fps||352 ft-lbs|
|Hornady Critical Duty 135 gr FlexLock +P||1,213 fps||441 ft-lbs|
|HPR Ammunition 115 gr JHP||1,258 fps||404 ft-lbs|
|HPR Ammunition 124 gr JHP||1,076 fps||319 ft-lbs|
|Liberty Ammunition 50 gr JHP||2,473 fps||679 ft-lbs|
|Remington UMC 115 gr JHP||1,277 fps||416 ft-lbs|
|Remington UMC Target 115 gr MC||1,210 fps||374 ft-lbs|
|Winchester 115 gr JHP (white box)||1,276 fps||416 ft-lbs|
Performance measured with a Competition Electronics ProChrono Digital Chronograph at an approximate distance of 15' from the muzzle of the pistol. All measurements are an average of five shots.
The 10.5â€ barrel seemed to give a lot of the ammo loads a boost of speed, with some loads receiving a more pronounced boost than others. In general, increasing a barrel length tends to increase velocity to a point. Shoot a .357 Magnum load from a 2â€ revolver and then from a 6â€ revolver. Ammo shot from the longer barrel gun will be significantly faster than when the load is shot in the snubby.
However, speed increases from barrel length do have a tipping point where the velocity will actually be reduced because the barrel is too long. Different calibers and loads within those calibers will perform differently with varying barrel lengths. Using the .357 Magnum as an example again, a 16″ barrel is likely to give a velocity increase over then 6″ barrel, but a rifle with a 32″ barrel might show a decrease from the 16″ – or even 6″ – barrel.
In general, velocity of 9mm ammo in the 10.5â€ barreled BCP was measurablyÂ increased when compared to shorter barreled handguns. Consider the Hornady Critical Duty 135 grain +P load. In another of my reviews, this ammo averaged 1,061 fps from the 4.09â€ barrel of HK VP9. That same load ran 152 fps faster from the Black Creek Precision gun. That equates to an increase of more than 14% and 100 ft-lbs of energy. (Note: I have a full review of the Hornady Critical Duty ammo here. The review includes data from many different guns.)
Benefitting the most from the increased barrel length was the Civil Defense ammo from Liberty Ammunition. Like the other loads I shot, these rounds were very accurate and had very little recoil. However, running them across the chronograph was quite interesting. On average, these 50 grain bullets were screaming along at 2,473 fps! From the VP9, the same load averaged 2,057 fps. So, the longer barrel added more than 400 fps and 200 ft-lbs of energy to the load.
Compare those numbers to AR pistols chambered in .223 Rem. In my experience, a premium 55 grain .223 round will produce between 2,100 â€“ 2,250 fps from a similar length barrel. However, the .223 round also produces significantly more recoil and muzzle blast.
There are definite differences between the 9mm bullet and .22 caliber bullet designs, and I am not naÃ¯ve enough to think it is an apples to apples comparison. However, at these velocities a light 9mm round that produces this kind of velocity with less recoil and muzzle blast than the .223 is worth considering for home defense or even tactical operations.
Black Creek Precision may not be a name you are familiar with, but if this pistol is any indication, you should be. The BCP 9mm pistol runs flawlessly, looks good and is fun to shoot. Even after running hundreds of rounds through the gun, the gun was utterly reliable. Even the finish on the pistol and the magazines was in excellent condition after my less-than-elegant operation of the weapon.
With the longer barrel, 9mm ammunition runs faster and hits harder without an increase in recoil or muzzle flash. The addition of a sound suppressor would reduce harmful noise and make the gun even more controllable.
Is it the ideal home defense gun? Thatâ€™s for you to decide. However, I do think that it has a lot of potential by offering better performance than a traditional handgun, while having less recoil and blast than a rifle.
It is my intention to provide you, the reader, with the best information possible when researching guns andÂ shooting gear that you might purchase. I believe it is important that I share with you any possible biases that might have influenced my review so you can properly weigh my opinions on the gun.
First, Black Creek Precision provided this pistol to me on loan for the purposes of review. No promises of a positive review were offered by me or solicited by the company. To the best of my knowledge, the gun provided was a standard production firearm. No monies were exchanged or offered in return for doing this review.
Second, Black Creek Precision is not an advertiser or sponsor of this site, nor am I in any discussions with them to be one. I do not have any financial interests in Black Creek Precision.
Lastly,Â GunsHolstersAndGear.com is a for-profit website.Â I do not charge readers a dime to access the information I provide.
Some of the links on this page and site are affiliate links to companies like Amazon and Palmetto State Armory. These links take you to the products mentioned in the article. Should you decide to purchase something from one of those companies, I make a small commission.
The links do not change your purchase price. I do not get to see what any individual purchases.
Questions and comments about the review or disclosures can be left in the comment section below. I encourage everyone who has something to add to chime in. I do not know everything, and your experiences with this gun, 9mm ARs or any other topic can be a benefit to other readers.